Shoplifting

Shoplifting Defense Attorney in Evansville, IN

Experienced Representation for Theft Allegations

Being accused of shoplifting can be stressful and embarrassing, especially if you’ve never been involved in the criminal justice system before. Even a minor offense can carry lasting consequences, including criminal charges, fines, and a record that can affect your job, education, or housing opportunities. If you or your child has been charged with shoplifting, it is important to act quickly and speak with a defense attorney.



At the law office of John Andrew Goodridge, we help clients throughout Evansville and the surrounding areas fight shoplifting charges and protect their future. With over 30 years of criminal law experience, we know how these cases are prosecuted and how to build a defense that fits your situation.

What Is Shoplifting in Indiana?

Shoplifting is a form of theft that typically involves:

  • Taking merchandise from a store without paying
  • Concealing items with the intent to steal
  • Switching price tags to pay less
  • Using false returns to get cash or store credit
  • Assisting someone else in stealing merchandise


Shoplifting is often charged as theft under Indiana law. The severity of the charge depends on the value of the items and any prior offenses.

  • Under $750: Usually charged as a Class A misdemeanor
  • $750 to $50,000: May be charged as a Level 6 felony
  • Over $50,000: Charged as a Level 5 felony


Even if the item is of low value, a conviction can leave a permanent mark on your record.

Defending Against Shoplifting Charges

Every case is different, and there may be valid defenses available to you. We will investigate whether:

  • You lacked intent to steal
  • There was a misunderstanding or mistake
  • You were misidentified
  • The store’s security procedures were flawed
  • Your rights were violated during the search or arrest


Our goal is to reduce or dismiss the charges and avoid long-term consequences. In many cases, we can negotiate alternative resolutions such as diversion programs or conditional dismissals for first-time offenders.

Serving Clients Across Southern Indiana

We represent clients charged with shoplifting in Evansville, Boonville, Chandler, Cynthiana, Darmstadt, Fort Branch, Haubstadt, Mount Vernon, Newburgh, Petersburg, Princeton, Poseyville, Rockport, and Wadesville. Contact our office today to schedule a confidential consultation.

A black and white drawing of a scale of justice on a white background.

Need Legal Help?

Contact our office today to schedule a confidential consultation and get the experienced legal support you need.

Why Choose John Andrew Goodridge?

  • Over 30 years of legal experience
  • Proven track record in Indiana courts
  • Focused, personalized attention on every case
  • Clear communication and honest guidance
  • Trusted by clients across Evansville and surrounding areas
  • Strong trial experience and skilled negotiation
  • Committed to protecting your rights and best interests

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Will I go to jail for a first-time shoplifting charge?

    Not necessarily. First-time offenders may be eligible for alternative sentencing or diversion programs that help avoid jail time and keep your record clean.

  • What if I forgot to pay for an item by accident?

    Intent is an important part of any theft charge. If you did not mean to steal the item, we may be able to present that as a defense in your case.

  • Can I be charged even if I didn’t leave the store?

    Yes. In some cases, concealing an item or switching a tag with the intent to steal is enough to lead to charges, even if you never left the building.

  • Will this show up on my record?

    If you are convicted, yes. A shoplifting charge will appear on your criminal record unless it is later expunged. We work to prevent convictions and protect your future.

  • Can shoplifting charges be dismissed?

    In many cases, yes. We may be able to negotiate a dismissal or reduced charge depending on your record, the value of the item, and the circumstances of the case.

Contact Us to Discuss Your Case

If you're facing a legal challenge, don’t navigate it alone. John Andrew Goodridge, Attorney at Law, is here to help you understand your rights and pursue the best possible outcome. We proudly serve clients in Evansville and surrounding areas, including Boonville, Chandler, Cynthiana, Darmstadt, Fort Branch, Haubstadt, Mount Vernon, Newburgh, Petersburg, Princeton, Poseyville, Rockport, and Wadesville. Reach out today to schedule a consultation.